Elkton Goodfellas: Your Go-To Spot for Delicious Pizza and Subs in Elkton, VA

Decent place to get pizza, subs, sandwiches, or pasta without breaking the bank. Inside is not fancy, service was hometown friendly and quick. Expect 20 - 30 minutes wait during lunch hours. The owner has closed two out of six tables in the restaurant to keep dine in customers at a safe distance. Fork and knife are individually stored in a disposable bag. We have ordered three slices of pizza, meatballs parmigiana, and steak & cheese special. Pizzas were very good, definitely worth of five stars, however both subs were nothing special. I have mix feelings about this place, you will have to try and be the judge.

What a wonderful diner! The service was friendly, cheerful, and attentive. Of course, the food was excellent. We are visiting in the area and try to eat at local establishments. If you are in Elkton, VA area stop here.

I got a tuna sub from here, it was pretty good. The pickles should’ve been cut up more though. The staff isn’t very friendly, kind of rude I’d say

Over all experience was amazing, our waitress Karé was the sweetest and on top of her game.. the food potions was bigger than expected for the prices as well.. was just in town for the day but will be back next time I'm in town! Also thank you to whoever paid for our meals! Never had that happen before! Great vibes there. On a side note I took my picture while I was already digging in.. I expected half of what I received based off past experiences elsewhere.. definitely get your money's worth!

Love this little place! We were on our way back from Luray and saw Goodfellas. We had to stop and check it out. The food was great, priced well and fast. Our waitress made us feel like home and we will definitely be back when we pass through.

I'd made a reservation at a fancy restaurant for Valentine's Day, but the wait to be seated was long and we decided not to stay. On our way home my wife asked if we could get a steak & cheese sub from Goodfellas diner? I said "for our Valentines's Day meal?; she said "yes, I'd like that." My wife was correct. The steak & cheese was delicious, hot, high-quality meat & veggies, joined with hot onion rings, fried in a home made batter. And the servers were friendly and attentive. Goodfellas saved my Valentine's Day. Anthony Bailey

Our food was great, the waiter was very polite and constantly checked on us to make sure everything was ok and made sure our drinks stayed full even though the place was full. Could definitely use more seating as it usually fills up pretty quick during lunch and dinner but it's worth the wait if there is any.

This place was jumping, and apparently, it's always jumping. The food was very good and the service was pretty fast.